Examining the Pros and Cons of Electric Community Choice Aggregation (CCA): A Consumer’s Guide”

March 13, 2024 at 5:34 pm

In the quest for cleaner and more affordable energy options, Electric Community Choice Aggregation (CCA) has emerged as a potential solution. While it promises benefits for consumers, there are crucial considerations that individuals should weigh before participating in such programs. This article delves into the potential disadvantages associated with CCAs, emphasizing the need for consumers to carefully evaluate the implications and make informed decisions. From limited individual choice to the challenges of market risks and administrative complexities, understanding the drawbacks is essential for those navigating the landscape of community-driven energy initiatives. Discover the intricacies of CCAs and learn how consumers can actively engage in discussions and stay informed to align their energy choices with personal preferences and priorities.


While Electric Community Choice Aggregation (CCA) can offer benefits to consumers, there are also potential disadvantages to consider:

  1. Limited Individual Choice: Consumers participating in a CCA may have limited control over the choice of their electricity supplier. The community or CCA administrator often makes decisions on behalf of all participants, potentially reducing individual choice and flexibility.
  2. Opt-Out Structure: CCAs typically operate on an opt-out basis, meaning residents are automatically enrolled unless they actively choose not to participate. Some consumers may prefer to have more control over their energy choices and may find the opt-out structure inconvenient or restrictive.
  3. Potential for Higher Costs: While one of the goals of CCAs is often to provide cost savings, there is a potential risk that the chosen electricity procurement strategy may not result in lower costs for consumers. Factors such as market fluctuations, contract terms, and administrative costs could impact overall expenses.
  4. Uncertainty in Renewable Energy Supply: CCAs often emphasize increasing the use of renewable energy, but the stability and availability of renewable energy sources can be uncertain. Consumers may be concerned about the reliability of a CCA’s commitment to sustainable energy sources.
  5. Administrative Challenges: Consumers may experience challenges related to billing, customer service, or communication within the CCA framework. Administrative issues could lead to confusion, delays, or dissatisfaction among participants.
  6. Potential Lack of Transparency: Some consumers might find it challenging to navigate the complexities of CCA programs, including understanding the terms of electricity supply contracts, the mix of energy sources, and associated costs. Lack of transparency could lead to consumer distrust.
  7. Dependency on CCA Decisions: Consumers may become dependent on the decisions made by the CCA, with limited influence over the electricity procurement strategy. This lack of control could be a concern for those who prefer more direct involvement in choosing their energy sources.

It’s essential for consumers to carefully review the terms and conditions of the CCA, assess the potential risks and benefits, and determine whether the program aligns with their preferences and priorities. Engaging in community discussions and staying informed about the CCA’s operations can help consumers make informed decisions.

If you want to review electric rate offers for your home from electric suppliers in the Orange & Rockland or Central Hudson service territories please visit our website:  M&R Energy Resources Corporation ( or call us:  866-610-SAVE(7283).